altReboot
  • Startup
  • Growth Hacking
  • Marketing
  • Automation
  • Blockchain Tech
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Contact
    • Write For Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Startup
  • Growth Hacking
  • Marketing
  • Automation
  • Blockchain Tech
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Contact
    • Write For Us
No Result
View All Result
altReboot
No Result
View All Result
Home Artificial Intelligence

AI could make healthcare fairer—by helping us believe what patients tell us

Karen Hao by Karen Hao
January 22, 2021
in Artificial Intelligence
Public policies in the age of digital disruption
0
SHARES
1
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

This post originally appeared on MIT Technology Review

In the last few years, research has shown that deep learning can match expert-level performance in medical imaging tasks like early cancer detection and eye disease diagnosis. But there’s also cause for caution. Other research has shown that deep learning has a tendency to perpetuate discrimination. With a healthcare system already riddled with disparities, sloppy applications of deep learning could make that worse.

Now a new paper published in Nature Medicine is proposing a way to develop medical algorithms that might help reverse, rather than exacerbate, existing inequality. The key, says Ziad Obermeyer, an associate professor at UC Berkeley who oversaw the research, is to stop training algorithms to match human expert performance.

Related articles

Public policies in the age of digital disruption

“We’ll never have true AI without first understanding the brain”

March 3, 2021
Public policies in the age of digital disruption

What is an “algorithm”? It depends whom you ask

February 26, 2021

The paper looks at a specific clinical example of the disparities that exist in the treatment of knee osteoarthritis, an ailment which causes chronic pain. Assessing the severity of that pain helps doctors prescribe the right treatment, including physical therapy, medication, or surgery. This is traditionally done by a radiologist reviewing an X-ray of the patient’s knee and scoring their pain on the Kellgren–Lawrence grade (KLG), which calculates pain levels based on the presence of different radiographic features, like the degree of missing cartilage or structural damage.

But data collected by the National Institute of Health found that doctors using this method systematically score Black patients far below the severity of pain that they say they’re experiencing. Patients self-report their pain levels using a survey that asks about pain during various activities, such as fully straightening their knee. But these self-reported pain levels are ignored in preference of the radiologist’s KLG score when prescribing treatment. In other words, Black patients who show the same amount of missing cartilage as white patients self-report higher levels of pain.

This has consistently miffed medical experts. One hypothesis goes that Black patients could be reporting higher levels of pain in order to get doctors to treat them more seriously. But there’s an alternative explanation. The KLG methodology itself could be biased. It was developed several decades ago based on white British populations. Some medical experts argue that the list of radiographic markers that it tells clinicians to look for may not include all the possible physical sources of pain within a more diverse population. Put another way, there may be radiographic indicators of pain that appear more commonly in Black people that simply aren’t part of the KLG rubric.

To test this possibility, the researchers trained a deep-learning model to predict the patient’s self-reported pain level from their knee x-ray. If the resultant model had terrible accuracy, this would suggest that self-reported pain is rather arbitrary. But if the model had really good accuracy, this would provide evidence that self-reported pain is in fact correlated with radiographic markers in the x-ray.

After running several experiments, including to discount any confounding factors, the researchers found that the model was much more accurate than KLG at predicting self-reported pain levels for both white and Black patients, but especially for Black patients. It reduced the racial disparity at each pain level by nearly half.

The goal isn’t necessarily to start using this algorithm in a clinical setting. But by outperforming the KLG methodology, it revealed that the standard way of measuring pain is flawed, at a much greater cost to Black people. This should tip off the medical community to investigate which radiographic markers the algorithm might be seeing, and update their scoring methodology.

“It actually highlights a really exciting part of where these kinds of algorithms can fit into the process of medical discovery,” says Obermeyer. “It tells us if there’s something here that’s worth looking at that we don’t understand. It sets the stage for humans to then step in and, using these algorithms as tools, try to figure out what’s going on.”

“The cool thing about this paper is it is thinking about things from a completely different perspective,” says Irene Chen, a researcher at MIT who studies how to reduce health care inequities in machine learning and was not involved in the paper. Instead of training the algorithm based on well-established expert knowledge, she says, the researchers chose to treat the patient’s self-assessment as truth. Through that it uncovered important gaps in what the medical field usually considers to be the more “objective” pain measure.

“That was exactly the secret,” agrees Obermeyer. If algorithms are only ever trained to match expert performance, he says, they will simply perpetuate existing gaps and inequities. “This study is a glimpse of a more general pipeline that we are increasingly able to use in medicine for generating new knowledge.”

ShareTweet

Related Posts

Public policies in the age of digital disruption

“We’ll never have true AI without first understanding the brain”

by Will Heaven
March 3, 2021
0

The search for AI has always been about trying to build machines that think—at least in some sense. But the...

Public policies in the age of digital disruption

What is an “algorithm”? It depends whom you ask

by Amy Nordrum
February 26, 2021
0

Describing a decision-making system as an “algorithm” is often a way to deflect accountability for human decisions. For many, the...

Public policies in the age of digital disruption

An AI is training counselors to deal with teens in crisis

by Abby Ohlheiser
February 26, 2021
0

Counselors volunteering at the Trevor Project need to be prepared for their first conversation with an LGBTQ teen who may...

10 Breakthrough Technologies 2021

10 Breakthrough Technologies 2021

by David Rotman
February 24, 2021
0

This list marks 20 years since we began compiling an annual selection of the year’s most important technologies. Some, such...

Why covid-19 might finally usher in the era of health care based on a patient’s data

Why covid-19 might finally usher in the era of health care based on a patient’s data

by Katie McLean
February 24, 2021
0

Back in the 1990s, Lee Hood, a technologist and immunologist famous for co-­inventing the automated DNA sequencer, made a bold...

Load More
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
7 Advanced SEO Strategies I’m Trying to Implement Before 2020

7 Advanced SEO Strategies I’m Trying to Implement Before 2020

September 10, 2019
What Do Successful Sales Look Like for the Rest of 2020?

13 Expert Tips to Increase Online Conversions in 2020

September 26, 2020
Creating SEO-friendly how-to content

Creating SEO-friendly how-to content

October 24, 2019

How to Start and Fund a Coffee Shop

September 30, 2019
A Beginner’s Guide to Facebook Insights

A Beginner’s Guide to Facebook Insights

0

Which Social Media Sites Really Matter and Why

0
The 12 Ironclad Rules for Issuing Press Releases

The 12 Ironclad Rules for Issuing Press Releases

0
How to Get Started Building Links for SEO

How to Get Started Building Links for SEO

0

How to Find and Grow Your Amazon Sales Rank

March 4, 2021
How to Make an App When You Can't Code (a Step-by-Step Guide)

Are You Coming Across as Authentic?

March 4, 2021

How to Find Keywords Everywhere

March 4, 2021
Are You an Influencer? Then You Better Understand These 5 Key Audience 'Tudes.

Are You an Influencer? Then You Better Understand These 5 Key Audience 'Tudes.

March 4, 2021
altReboot




altREBOOT is committed to sharing the game changing advancements that are revolutionizing how you do business. From startup to goliath, innovations in technology are changing the face of the business landscape. We are committed to exploring these and how to apply them to your business at any stage of development.





Categories

  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Blockchain Tech
  • Growth Hacking
  • Marketing
  • Startup
  • Uncategorized

Tags

blockchain branding guest post marketing mobile apps
  • Home
  • Topics
  • Write For Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact

Powered By Treehouse 51

No Result
View All Result
  • Startup
  • Growth Hacking
  • Marketing
  • Automation
  • Blockchain Tech
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Contact
    • Write For Us